SHE BEING DEAD YET SPEAKETH
[In the will of the late H. P. Blavatsky was made the request
that her friends should assemble on the anniversary of her death
and read passages from the Bhagavad-Gita and the Light
of Asia. This was accordingly done on May 8th, in Adyar, London,
New York, and other places. In New York, among other interesting
items reported at the time, Mrs. J. Campbell Keightley read, after
a few introductory remarks, extracts from the private letters
of H.P.B. In response to many requests we print these as follows.
The remarks, being extemporaneous, are quoted from memory.]
MR. PRESIDENT, FRIENDS:
This being the first occasion upon which I have ever spoken in
public, I will ask you to condone my inexperience while I make
a few remarks upon the extracts chosen from the letters of Madame
Blavatsky to a few friends.
In regard to Mme. Blavatsky, the world, to use a phrase of Charles
Lamb, was "the victim of imperfect sympathies." It failed
to know her; that failure was its own great loss. Among the many
accusations flung at her was one which, at the last ditch, it
never failed to make; it said that Mme. Blavatsky had no Moral
Ideal. This was false.
She had this ideal; she had also the Eastern reverence for an
ideal--a reverence to the Western world unknown. We might hence
expect to find her teaching that Ideal to a great extent under
the privacy of a pledge, and there are indications of this in
all that has been published concerning the Esoteric School. That
her ideal was ever present to her mind and heart these extracts
from private letters to her friends will show.
Her main teachings can be reduced to the following propositions:
That Morals have a basis in Law and in fact.
That Moral Law is Natural Law.
That Evolution makes for Righteousness.
That the "fundamental identity of all souls with the Oversoul"
renders moral contagion possible through the subtle psychic medium.
That the Spiritual Identity of all Being renders Universal Brotherhood
the only possible path for truth-seeking men.
She distrusted the appeal to sentiment. She saw that existing
religions fail in it; that modern civilization frustrates it;
that emotionalism is no basis for the Will which annuls all temptations
of the flesh, and the Faith which shall make mountains move.
Hence she taught the scientific aspect and bearing of sin.
Taught that Universal Law, in every department, rigidly opposes
and avenges the commission of sin, showing the free will of man
counterbalanced by the declaration "Vengeance is mine, saith
the Law; I will repay." She taught that the
awful responsibility of the occultist, extending down to the least
atom of substance, forever forbade our asking that question of
Cain which we do ask daily--"Am I my Brother's keeper?"
She taught that the deep reply reverberated down the ages, as
we may read it in our bibles: "What hast thou done? The voice
of thy brother's blood crieth to me from the ground."
Justice she taught, and the true discrimination of it; Mercy,
too, and Love. She wrote of one: "He has developed an extraordinary
hatred to me, but I have loved him too much to hate him."
Above all she taught that "the pure in heart see God";
taught it as a scientific fact; showed it to be, so to say, materially
as well as spiritually possible through the spiritual laws working
in the one Substance, and, in the showing, lifted our courage
higher than the visible stars.
The first of these extracts from H.P.B.'s letters is dated Nov.
29, 1878, and is interesting from the fact that it speaks of the
original institution of three degrees of the T.S., a fact often
disputed in these later days.
YOU will find the aims and purposes of the
Theosophical Society in the two inclosed circulars. It is a brotherhood
of humanity, established to make away with all and every dogmatic
religion founded on dead-letter interpretation, and to teach people
and every member to believe but in one impersonal God; to rely
upon his (man's) own powers; to consider himself his only saviour;
to learn the infinitude of the occult psychological powers hidden
within his own physical man; to develop these powers; and to give
him the assurance of the immortality of his divine spirit and
the survival of his soul; to make him regard every man of whatever
race, color, or creed, and to prove to him that the only truths
revealed to man by superior men (not a god) are contained in the
Vedas of the ancient Aryas of India. Finally, to demonstrate to
him that there never were, will be, nor are, any miracles; that
there can be nothing 'supernatural' in this universe, and that
on earth, at least, the only god is man himself.
"It lies within his powers to become and to continue a god
after the death of his physical body. Our society receives nothing
the possibility of which it cannot demonstrate at will. We believe
in the phenomena, but we disbelieve in the constant intervention
of 'spirits' to produce such phenomena. We maintain that the embodied
spirit has more powers to produce them than a disembodied one.
We believe in the existence of spirits, but of many classes, the
human spirits being but one class of the many.
"The Society requires of its members but the time they can
give it without encroaching upon that due to their private affairs.
There are three degrees of membership. It is but in the highest
or third that members have to devote themselves quasi entirely
to the work of the T.S. . . .
"Everyone is eligible, provided he is an honest, pure man
or woman, no free lover, and especially no bigoted Christian.
We go dead against idolatry, and as much against materialism."
"Of the two unpardonable sins, the first is Hypocrisy--Pecksniffianism.
Better one hundred mistakes through unwise, injudicious sincerity
and indiscretion than Tartuffe-like saintship as the whitened
sepulchre, and rottenness and decay within. . . . This is not unpardonable,
but very dangerous, . . . doubt, eternal wavering--it leads one
to wreck. . . . One little period passed without doubt, murmuring,
and despair; what a gain it would be; a period a mere tithe of
what every one of us has had to pass through. But every one forges
his own destiny."
"Those who fall off from our living human Mahatmas
to fall into the Saptarishi--the Star Rishis, are no Theosophists."
"Allow me to quote from a very esoterically wise and exoterically
foolish book, the work and production of some ancient friends
and foes: 'There is more joy in the Kingdom of Heaven for one
repentant sinner than for ninety-nine saints.' . . . Let us be
just and give to Caesar what is Caesar's, however imperfect, even
vicious, Caesar may be. 'Blessed be the peacemakers,' said another
old adept of 107 years B.C., and the saying is alive and kicks
to the present day amongst the MASTERS."
"The Esoteric Section is to be a School for earnest Theosophists
who would learn more (than they can from published works) of the
true Esoteric tenets. . . . There is no room for despotism or ruling
in it; no money to pay or make; no glory for me, but a series
of misconceptions, slanders, suspicions, and ingratitude in almost
an immediate future:1 but if out of the . . .
have already pledged themselves I can place on the right and true
path half a dozen or so, I will die happy. Many are called, few
are chosen. Unless they comply with the lines you speak of, traced
originally by the Masters, they cannot succeed.2 I can
only show the way to those whose eyes are open to the truth, whose
souls are full of altruism, charity, and love for the whole creation,
and who think of themselves last. The blind . . . will
never profit by these teachings. They would make of the 'strait
gate' a large public thoroughfare leading not to the Kingdom of
Heaven, now and hereafter, to the Buddha-Christos in the Sanctuary
of our innermost souls, but to their own idols with feet of clay. . . .
The Esoteric Section is not of the earth, earthy; it does not
interfere with the exoteric administration of Lodges; takes no
stock in external Theosophy; has no officers or staff;
needs no halls or meeting rooms. . . . Finally, it requires neither
subscription fees nor money, for 'as I have not so received it,
I shall not so impart it,' and that I would rather starve
in the gutter than take one penny for my teaching of the sacred
truths. . . . Here I am with perhaps a few years or a few months
only (Master knoweth) to remain on earth in this loathsome, old,
ruined body; and I am ready to answer the call of any good Theosophist
who works for Theosophy on the lines traced by the Masters,
and as ready as the Rosicrucian pelican to feed with my heart's
blood the chosen 'Seven.' He who would have his inheritance before
I die . . . let him ask first. What I have, or rather what I am
permitted to give, I will give."
"Many are called but few are chosen. Well, no need breaking
my heart over spilt milk. Come what may, I shall die at my post,
Theosophical banner in hand, and while I live I do fervently
hope that all the splashes of mud thrown at it will reach me personally.
At any rate I mean to continue protecting the glorious truth with
my old carcass so long as it lasts. And when I do drop down for
good, I hope in such Theosophists as . . . and . . . to carry
on the work and protect the banner of Truth in their turn. Oh,
I do feel so sick at heart in looking round and perceiving nothing
save selfishness, personal vanity, and mean little ambitions.
What is this about 'the soldier not being free'?3 Of
soldier can be free to move about his physical body wherever he
likes. But what has the esoteric teaching to do with the outward
man? A soldier may be stuck to his sentry box like a barnacle
to its ship, and the soldier's Ego be free to go where it likes
and think what it likes best. . . . No man is required to carry a
burden heavier than he can bear; nor do more than it is possible
for him to do. A man of means, independent and free from any duty,
will have to move about and go, missionary-like, to teach Theosophy
to the Sadducees and the Gentiles of Christianity. A man tied
by his duty to one place has no right to desert it in order to
fulfill another duty, let it be however much greater; for the
first duty taught in Occultism is to do one's duty unflinchingly
by every duty. Pardon these seemingly absurd paradoxes
and Irish Bulls; but I have to repeat this ad nauseam usque
for the last month. 'Shall I risk to be ordered to leave my
wife, desert my children and home if I pledge myself?' asks one.
'No,' I say, 'because he who plays truant in one thing will be
faithless in another. No real, genuine MASTER
will accept a chela who sacrifices anyone except himself
to go to that Master.' If one cannot, owing to circumstances or
his position in life, become a full adept in this existence, let
him prepare his mental luggage for the next, so as to be ready
at the first call when he is once more reborn. What one has to
do before he pledges himself irretrievably is, to probe one's
nature to the bottom, for self-discipline is based on self-knowledge.
It is said somewhere that self-discipline often leads one to a
state of self-confidence which becomes vanity and pride in the
long run. I say, foolish is the man who says so. This may happen
only when our motives are of a worldly character or selfish; otherwise,
self-confidence is the first step to that kind of WILL
which will make a mountain move:
" 'To thine own self be true, and it must follow, as the
night the day, thou can'st not then be false to any man.'
"The question is whether Polonius meant this for worldly
wisdom or for occult knowledge; and by 'own self' the false
Ego (or the terrestrial personality) or that spark in us which
is but the reflection of the 'One Universal Ego.'
"But I am dreaming. I had but four hours' sleep. . . . Give
my sincere, fraternal respects to . ., and let him try to feel
my old hand giving him the Master's grip, the strong grip
of the Lion's paw of Punjab (not of the tribe of Judah) across
the Atlantic. To you my eternal affection and gratitude.
"To live like cats and dogs in the T.S. is positively
against all rules--and wishes of 'the Masters,' as against
our Brotherhood-- so-called--and all its rules. THEY are disgusted.
THEY look on, and in that look (oh Lord! if
you could only see it as I have!) there's an ocean deep of sad
disgust, contempt, and sorrow. . . . The ideal was besmeared with
mud, but as it is no golden idol on feet of clay it stands to
this day immovable . . . and what the profane see is only their
own mud thrown with their own hands, and which has created a veil,
an impassable barrier between them and the ideal . . . without
touching the latter. . . . Have a large Society, the more the better;
all that is chaff and husk is bound to fall away in time; all
that is grain will remain. But the seed is in the bad and
evil man as well as in the good ones,--only it is more difficult
to call into life and cause it to germinate. The good husbandman
does not stop to pick out the seeds from the handful. He gives
them all their chance, and even some of the half-rotten seeds
come to life when thrown into good soil. Be that soil. . . . Look
at me--the universal Theosophical manure--the rope for whose hanging
and lashing is made out of the flax I have sown, and each strand
it is twisted of represents a 'mistake' (so-called) of mine. Hence,
if you fail only nine times out of ten in your selections you
are successful one time out of ten--and that's more than many
other Theosophists can say. . . . Those few true souls will be the
nucleus for future success, and their children will. . . . Let us
sow good--and if evil crops up, it will be blown away by the wind
like all other things in this life--in its time."
"I am the Mother and the Creator of the Society; it has my
magnetic fluid, and the child has inherited all of its parent's
physical, psychical, and spiritual attributes--faults and virtues
if any. Therefore I alone and to a degree . . . can serve as a
lightning conductor of Karma for it. I was asked whether I was
willing, when on the point of dying--and I said Yes--for it was
the only means to save it. Therefore I consented to live--which
in my case means to suffer physically during twelve hours of the
day--mentally twelve hours of night, when I get rid of the physical
shell. . . . It is true about the Kali Yuga. Once that I have offered
myself as the goat of atonement, the Kali Yuga4
own--whereas any other would shrink from such a thing--as I am
doomed and overburdened in this life worse than a poor weak donkey
full of sores made to drag up hill a cart load of heavy rocks.
You are the first one to whom I tell it, because you force
me into the confession. . . .You have a wide and noble prospect before
you if you do not lose patience. . . . Try to hear the small voice
"Yes, there are 'two persons' in me. But what of that? So
there are two in you; only mine is conscious and responsible--and
yours is not. So you are happier than I am. I know you sympathise
with me, and you do so because you feel that I have always stood
up for you, and will do so to the bitter or the happy end--as
the case may be."
"He may be moved to doubt--and that is the beginning of wisdom."
"Well, sir, and my only friend, the crisis is nearing.
I am ending my Secret Doctrine, and you are going
to replace me, or take my place in America. I know you will
have success if you do not lose heart; but do, do remain true
to the Masters and Their Theosophy and the names. . . .
May They help you and allow us to send you our best
blessings. . . ."
"There are traitors, conscious and unconscious. There
is falsity and there is injudiciousness. . . . Pray do not imagine
that because I hold my tongue as bound by my oath and duty
I do not know who is who. . . . I must say nothing, however much
I may be disgusted. But as the ranks thin around us, and one after
the other our best intellectual forces depart, to turn into bitter
enemies, I say--Blessed are the pure-hearted who have only intuition--for
intuition is better than intellect."
"The duty,--let alone happiness--of every Theosophist--and
especially Esotericist--is certainly to help others to carry their
burden; but no Theosophist or other has the right to sacrifice
himself unless he knows for a certainty that by so doing
he helps some one and does not sacrifice himself in vain for the
empty glory of the abstract virtue. . . . Psychic and vital energy
are limited in every man. It is like a capital. If you have a
dollar a day and spend two, at the end of the month you will have
a deficit of $30."
"One refuses to pledge himself not to listen without protest
to any evil thing said of a brother--as though Buddha our divine
Lord-- or Jesus--or any great initiate has ever condemned any
one on hearsay. Ah, poor, poor, blind man, not to know the difference
between condemning in words--which is uncharitable--and withdrawing
in silent pity from the culprit and thus punishing him, but still
giving him a chance to repent of his ways. No man will ever speak
ill of his brother without cause and proof of the iniquity of
that brother, and he will abstain from all backbiting, slandering,
and gossip. No man should ever say behind a Brother's back what
he would not say openly to his face. Insinuations against one's
neighbor are often productive of more evil consequences than gross
slander. Every Theosophist has to fight and battle against evil,--but
he must have the courage of his words and actions, and what he
does must be done openly and honestly before all."
"Every pledge or promise unless built upon four pillars--absolute
sincerity, unflinching determination, unselfishness of purpose,
and moral power, which makes the fourth support and equipoises
the three other pillars--is an insecure building. The pledges
of those who are sure of the strength of the fourth alone are
"Are you children, that you want marvels? Have you so little
faith as to need constant stimulus, as a dying fire needs fuel!
. . . Would you let the nucleus of a splendid Society die under
your hands like a sick man under the hands of a quack? . . . You
should never forget what a solemn thing it is for us to exert
our powers and raise the dread sentinels that lie at the threshold.
They cannot hurt us, but they can avenge themselves by precipitating
themselves upon the unprotected neophyte. You are all like so
many children playing with fire because it is pretty, when you
ought to be men studying philosophy for its own sake."
"If among you there was one who embodied in himself the idea
depicted, it would be my duty to relinquish the teacher's chair
to him. For it would be the extreme of audacity in me to claim
the possession of so many virtues. That the MASTERS
do in proportion to their respective temperaments and stages
of Bodhisatvic development possess such Paramitas, constitutes
their right to our reverence as our Teachers. It should be the
aim of each and all of us to strive with all the intensity of
our natures to follow and imitate Them. . . . Try to realize that
progress is made step by step, and each step gained by heroic
effort. Withdrawal means despair or timidity. . . . Conquered
passions, like slain tigers, can no longer turn and rend you.
Be hopeful then, not despairing. With each morning's awakening
try to live through the day in harmony with the Higher Self. 'Try'
is the battle-cry taught by the teacher to each pupil. Naught
else is expected of you. One who does his best does
all that can be asked. There is a moment when even a Buddha
ceases to be a sinning mortal and takes his first step toward
Buddhahood. The sixteen Paramitas (virtues) are not for priests
and yogis alone, as said, but stand for models for us all to strive
after--and neither priest nor yogi, Chela nor Mahatma, ever attained
all at once. . . . The idea that sinners and not saints are expected
to enter the Path is emphatically stated in the Voice of the
"I do not believe in the success of the . . . T.S. unless
you assimilate Master or myself; unless you work with me
and THEM, hand in hand, heart. . . . Yes; let
him who offers himself to Masters as a chela, unreservedly, .
. . let him do what he can if he would ever see Them. . . .
Then things were done because I alone was responsible for the
issues. I alone had to bear Karma in case of failure and no
reward in case of success. . . . I saw the T.S. would be smashed
or that I had to offer myself as the Scapegoat for atonement.
It is the latter I did. The T.S. lives,--I am killed. Killed
in my honor, fame, name, in everything H.P.B. held near and dear,
for this body is MINE and I feel acutely through
it. . . . I may err in my powers as H.P.B. I have not worked and
toiled for forty years, playing parts, risking my future reward,
and taking karma upon this unfortunate appearance to serve Them
without being permitted to have some voice in the matter. H.P.B.
is not infallible. H.P.B. is an old, rotten, sick, worn-out body,
but it is the best I can have in this cycle. Hence follow the
path I show, the Masters that are behind--and do not follow me
or my PATH. When I am dead and gone in this
body, then will you know the whole truth. Then will you know that
I have never, never, been false to any one, nor have I
deceived anyone, but had many a time to allow them to deceive
themselves, for I had no right to interfere with their Karma. . . .
Oh ye foolish blind moles, all of you; who is able to offer himself
in sacrifice as I did!"
H. P. Blavatsky
Path, June, July, August, 1892
1 Dated December 1, 1888. Subsequent events proved the
back to text
2 Her correspondent had quoted the Simla letter of
"K.H." in The Occult World.
back to text
3 Referring to the dilemma of an F.T.S. soldier in the army,
presented to her.
back to text
4 Kali Yuga--the Dark Age, the present cycle.
back to text
"No Religion Higher Than Truth"
Support this site by visiting our donation page.
Site copyright © 1996-2014 by Estela Carson-Priede